Some people would answer YES, you can be redeemed and be gay. Those are the moderate and liberal Christians for whom the barn door was left open long ago and the horse ran off.
The plagues of the Exodus included rivers and streams turning into blood, a rain of hail mingled with fire, and impenetrable darkness in which people couldn't see their hands in front of their faces.
We (that's me and the Holy spirit) were asked the question: Can someone be redeemed and gay? We're going to use deductive reasoning to pick our way through this and see what we come up with.